Tuesday, February 3, 2026

The Gap in Immigration Attitudes

 The Hypocrisy Gap in Immigration Attitudes

Public opinion on immigration often splits in two: people support deporting "illegal immigrants" in the abstract, but oppose deporting the specific ones they know personally—like the gardener, the neighbor, the pastor, or the hardworking family.
  • Am honest friend once described himself as "a Republican in theory, but a Democrat in practice." He wants welfare cuts... just not for people he knows. He favors harsher punishment for criminals... except for the prisoners he sometimes works with, for whom he wants more mercy.
  • Another friend was genuinely upset when his long-time gardener—a pastor in a Spanish-language church—was deported. Yet when asked if he supports open borders, he said no.
This pattern isn't rare. People tend to like individuals but dislike the collective category they belong to.The Same Pattern Shows Up EverywhereThis "theory vs. practice" disconnect appears in many areas of American life:
  • Drugs — Strong support for drug laws in general, but reluctance to turn in friends or family who use.
  • Public schools — "The schools are failing," except "my kids' school is good."
  • Congress — "Congress is terrible," but "my representative is doing a fine job."
  • Personal vs. national outlook — Recent Gallup polls show ~81% of Americans are satisfied with their own lives, while only ~20% feel the same about the direction of the country.
  • Healthcare costs — About 57% are satisfied with what they personally pay for healthcare, but only ~16–20% are satisfied with U.S. healthcare costs overall.
  • Speeding laws — Broad support for the rules, but widespread frustration with speed cameras that enforce them.
Applying It to Immigration and Deportation
Most people who say they want closed borders aren't actually for open borders. Many of the protesters in places like Minnesota likely aren't demanding unrestricted entry—they're simply reacting against Trump (which is understandable given the polarization).Yet if someone truly wants controlled borders and effective enforcement (via ICE or a similar agency), they should be prepared for deportations that will inevitably include sympathetic cases: the long-term resident earning U.S.-level wages, the Chinese Christian family risking everything on the dangerous trek north, or the Honduran group holding prayer meetings and religious services along the journey.In my view, it can be more cruel to block someone who has spent their life savings to reach the border than to deport someone who has already built a life here. Loss aversion makes the latter feel worse, but the former is often the harsher outcome in reality.A Quick Aside on Politics and PersonnelTrump, Stephen Miller, Kristi Noem, Tom Homan (assuming Bovino refers to a similar figure), and others should arguably be removed from immigration roles if they publicly comment on specific deaths (like those of Alex Pretti and Renee Nicole Good) before trials conclude. Statements like that risk alienating voters and undermining broader support for increased deportations—the very goal they claim to pursue.Bottom LineAmericans are remarkably optimistic about their own circumstances while pessimistic about the nation as a whole. The same selective empathy applies to immigration: deport "them" in theory, but not the ones we see as individuals.The U.S. is still a remarkable country—capable, in my outlier opinion, of absorbing very large numbers of immigrants annually. A realistic compromise might be a large-scale guest-worker program, but that's a separate debate.In the meantime, for some counter-doom perspective, check out the "Doomslayer" compilation: 1,084 Reasons the World Isn’t Falling Apart from Human Progress. It's a useful reminder that things aren't collapsing as fast as the headlines suggest.What do you think—does this "I like my X, but hate the category" pattern explain more political contradictions than we usually admit?

Tuesday, January 27, 2026

Tyler Cowen Asks Why the Democrats are Fading.

Their policies have been tried and found to fail. Anti-police rhetoric and riot excuse making lead to a 30% increase in murder. The poor are no longer poor by consumption but still commit violent crime at twice the rate of the non poor and still don't do as well in school.

They, the party of peace, failed to deter war in Ukraine or negotiate out of it.

The people that they have sympathy for, the Gaza Palestinians lashed out in crazy and violent way.

The only thing that they have going for them is the craziness of the Trumpians and the weakness of Trump as a candidate and memories of Trump are fading.

Democratic Socialism

 Democratic means every person gets a vote.

Socialism means common ownership of everything.

So the voters have taken control over what can be built near them and have for very frivolous reasons blocked building driving up the cost of living.

Socialism means you have no property rights and no economic rights.

More Democratic Socialism is not the solution to high cost of living especially concerning housing.

Thursday, September 4, 2025

Recipe for Italian Pepper Biscuits

Pepper biscuits


1 ½ t yeast

237 grams warm water

580 grams flour

1 t salt/about 7 grams

3 t coarsely ground black peppercorns (I use a mortar and pestle)

1 t crushed red pepper

1 t Fennel seed

200 grams olive oil


Dissolve yeast in water. 

Add flour, salt, pepper, crushed red pepper, fennel seed onto a mixer. Mix for about a minute and stop. This is because dough should not be completely uniform so that the final product will have varying texture.

Add the oil and mix until everything is incorporated but the dough should not be uniform. 


Remove from the mixer and knead for a few minutes.


Place in oiled bowl, turn to coat, cover with a towel and let rise until doubled in bulk.

Preheat the oven to 400º. 


Split the dough into 32 pieces and roll into ropes about 6 inches long. 

Place on a baking sheet and let rise for 20 minutes.

Brush with oil, sprinkle with coarsely ground salt and bake for 12 to 15 minutes or until lightly browned.


Wednesday, April 23, 2025

Designing Better Health Insurance

I've been thinking of taking a shot at designing a health insurance plan closer to ideal. 

So far:

These are without regard to whether it is provided by Government or through an insurance company or some other organization.

It should be lifetime.

It should probably cover prenatal care and trauma care as preventive care.

If it were non-Government issued insurance this brings up the issue of when to sign up for it. Mothers would have to select into a plan at first sign of pregnancy or Government could subsidize those born with an expensive lifetime condition or who contract one before adulthood.

It should include a death benefit, disability insurance and cover long term care. The death benefit should decrease with age.

It should not pay for small things like MD appointments but should pay for and or require preventive care that has solid evidence of net reduction of disease.

The contract should start at conception or rather when the mother becomes aware that she is pregnant.

For a person/family with median age lifetime income and median lifetime healthcare it should pay for nothing until they get over median lifetime expenditures exceed median lifetime expenditure. Some subsidy of low earners might be needed.

It should do something along the lines of price negotiation for emergency care on behalf of the customer.

If a person goes outside the US for care they should get some of the savings.

If a patient forgoes some care, say at the end of life they should be rewarded like in Singapore.


I will add to this post as I think of more issues.

A Political Science Mystery

It seems to me that the populations of Vermont and North Dakota are very similar. Both are rural states with significant farm sectors. I'd guess that that the voters in those states prefer similar policy, so I am mystified that Vermont voted 64.4% for Harris and very similar North Dakota voted 67.5% for Trump.
What's up with that?

Thursday, December 26, 2024

The Slowing

We saw a slowing of per capita growth and an increase in income and wealth inequality starting in the early 1970's.

I present a few things that might be driving this trend.

One accelerating inflation

The 1970 was the end of a long period of accelerating inflation. Accelerating or unexpected inflation tends to help what I call commodity labor (that is worker that do jobs that almost anyone can do with a few hours of training).

This is because it fools businesses to thinking there is more demand for their products than there is and so to hire more employees.

Part 2 NIMBY

Some have contended that the reduction of Government action in the 1970's slowed economic growth and increased income inequality and lower quality of life for bottom 30% of earners. but it appears to that NIMBYism and a reduction in law enforcement are primarily to blame.

Here's an anonymous quote on the subject:

"Seeing the price of TVs falling down and down- and understanding that was capitalism." "Seeing the price of a flat in London going up and up and up- but being told this was also capitalism"

NIMBY has made it more expensive to build anything. Bryan Caplan says the top economist studying the rise in housing costs estimate that the typical US home is 2x as expensive due to NIMBY. NIMBY, though mostly a left generated movement is even slowing the expansion of green power.

Letting NIMBY's block owners from building is transferring some ownership to voters. In the 1970's people started to gain power to stop even residential building.

Here is Matt Rognelie of Massachusetts Institute of Technology answering the question of what is driving the growth in inequality he lands on NIMBY.

Not only does NIMBY make housing more expensive but also construction is large employer of men without college degrees and has historically paid more than the manufacturing jobs. 

It also increases inequality by keeping low earners from moving to places where pay is higher.

3 Crime

There was a rapid increase in measured crime and disorder in the mid 1960s. It might be measurement error (some contend that murders with Black victims were under reported prior to 1965), but it might be partly due to the Democratic, in attempt to reduce police and prison brutality went more with reduced sentences and getting criminals off, to punish the system rather than focusing all their efforts on reforming police and prisons. leading to more crime in poor areas degrading life and increasing divides that would impact inequality in standard of living. BTW it might even be that more police would lead to less abuse rather than more.

Tuesday, November 26, 2024

The optimal Tax rate for the Very Rich is Zero

The optimal tax rate for those who spend a small percentage of their income and invest the rest, like many billionaires, is 0.

Pigovian, LVT and progressive consumption taxes would be better than income and corporate taxes

Monopoly Pricing

People seem to assume that a monopoly's optimal price is much higher than it is. A monopoly business optimally prices where marginal revenue = marginal cost which is way below were people seem to imagine.

(BTW IMHO Governments can and do sometimes price much above that, they have less motivation to maximize goods and services or profits.)

Even an unregulated electric utility would probably not price much higher than they do with regulation and also since almost all monopoly utilities are regulated it is hard to know what the price should/would be


Here is a link presenting Joseph Schumpeter's theory that monopolies produce more innovation and so do not hurt consumers on net.

Thursday, September 19, 2024

Getting the Direction Wrong

Interesting debate here:

Is The American Dream Alive and Well?

David Leonhardt and Bhaskar Sunkara often get the direction wrong on many of the points that they make. Examples are drug deaths, divorce and lower rates of marriage. Those are more likely the result more wealth and opportunity. Let's face the awful fact that when some people have more ability to get drugs they use more and when women can earn a good living they can be more selective of whom they marry and stay with.

And when David Leonhardt and Bhaskar Sunkara did get the direction right that is on crime, a big part of the cause is on their side. Poor law enforcement in places where democrats control law enforcement (though the illegality of drugs is probably also a factor).

Let's try to stop crime before it occurs like some have argued has been done in New York city.

Thursday, February 22, 2024

My Biggest Governmental/Political Issues as of Feb 2024

  • The war in Ukraine - it looks to me like the failure to get a negotiated agreement to avoid the war was big foreign policy failure. Putin is an evil dictator but there have already been about 15,000 deaths and many more injuries. We should have pushed the Ukrainians to offer Russia the parts of where the majority of the people prefer to be part of Russia plus neutrality and no entrance to NATO. If he refused that then we have to support the war. Further Putin though an evil dictator unlike the communists in the old USSR allows people to live fairly normal lives as long as they stay away from politics and there is hope for change from within. As the US Government learned in Afghanistan, Governing a place were the people hate you is often not beneficial in the modern world, so Ukraine may make problems for Russia if they try to dominate it.  
  • Drug prohibition - it seems to me that the illegality of drugs though it may reduce recreational drug use a little on net is a negative. The war on drugs has been destructive to parts of Latin America and in parts of the country here. I think we should try legalizing the sale so users can be assured of some level of constancy in the supply. Hopefully that will reduce accidental overdose. Drug OD deaths are now over 100,000 per year and they have been doubling each decade at least since 1980, and some researchers say since 1940.
  • Euclidean zoning - Euclidean zoning allows people to stop building for frivolous reasons like increased traffic and neighborhood character. It is a denial of the right to build and develop and has driven housing costs up in the most desirable parts of the USA. It has contributed to homelessness particularly in west coast cities. The incentives being what they are in local politics, I think the Federal government needs to make it illegal.

  • Crime - Crime is mostly a local issue but, the US murder rate is much higher than other developed countries, and we have an example of how to reduce it in New York city were crime is much lower than it used to be. There is a debate about the importance of "stop and frisk" in New York's success, was mainly due to a reduction in corruption in the police force and how much if any of the reduction was due to immigration.  

  • Medical insurance reform -  the federal government pays for about 65% of healthcare in the US but Medicine is mostly regulated at the state and local level. That creates some undesirable incentives. So I think we should transfer more of the regulation of healthcare to the federal Government, or make the system more incentive compatible by having the Federal Government give the money that it would spent on healthcare to the states with the requirement that the cover people who are now on Medicare, the lowest income citizens (current on Medicaid) and all Federal government employees. The states can spend it in the most efficient way and if some money is left spend it on what they like. I've written about that and some other possible reforms.
  • Medicare reform - if we do not do the above we should have Medicare stop paying for stuff that the UK's MHS does not provide. That is care that has not shown a positive net benefit to cost from what I've read that seems to be at least 20% of Medicare spending. I've written about other reforms that might help reduce costs. 
  • Social Security reform - The system should stop giving COLA raises to the higher lifetime earners until all recipients receive the same payment in retirement. The system in Australia works that way, for the Government part of pensions, every retiree gets the same amount. It is and should a program to prevent the elderly from falling into poverty.
To me the issues we focus most on like immigration are problems but not as big as the above. Inflation has been a problem for the last few years but seems to be under control now.

Thursday, January 25, 2024

A Compromise with Drug Law Supporters

As a compromise with drug law supporters, I have begun to propose that we legalize the sale of all drugs, to make the supply safer, but make the use of certain recreational drugs without a prescription illegal. This would be to reduce the collateral damage from drug use, including spouse abuse and child abuse and street crime. That way if someone calls the police because a drugged up guy in behaving bad, the police can arrest and jail him and it is an easier conviction.

I would say that they could then force him into treatment but from the evidence that I've seen forced treatment doesn't work. Of course in the future it might and so we should keep it as an option.

A UBI Design Again

I support a $260/week UBI given to all US citizens over 18 years old but it would replace TANF, SNAP, minimum wage laws, housing subsidies etc. and yes Social Security also. There would no longer be a reason to have those programs if we had a UBI. And I think giving more money to parents for there children would dangerous in that a very few but not 0 might have children that they neglect to get more money and that would look bad for the UBI and in fact be bad. Children are already subsidized through schools and free lunch programs and charities like to help children and the UBI would make the problem of child poverty small enough that charity could cover it. I would also start taxing the 1st dollar earned at 33% instead of 15.2%. The tax rate/bracket could lowered once income goes about enough to pay for the UBI ($40,969.70/year). 

If it reduces would too much a work requirement can be added.

Monday, January 8, 2024

Factors in Increase in Homelessness

What has contributed to the increase in homelessness in the USA 

One factor seems to be deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill.

From google AI: “Studies from the late 1980s suggest that homelessness is related to deinstitutionalization”

Another factor especially on the west coast is the increase in voters ability to block the rights of land owners to build for frivolous reasons like increased traffic, neighborhood character etc. See Euclidian zoning.

Which BTW is an extreme form of democracy. It is related to Social Democracy which is a system where workers and citizens get to vote on much more. In a socialist Democracy employees would get to vote on how corporations are run and voters in an are would get to vote on what gets built and much more.

Another factor is the reduction of police power and courts standing up for the rights of those who end up homeless who might in an earlier time been put in jail. One might look at this as a good thing but can lead to more people living on the streets.

Homelessness is a common problem now in most developed countries. Japan seems have overcome it by putting zoning in control of the national government. The national government represents the people in a given area but also the people who would like to live in that area.

Friday, November 3, 2023

How Much Would a CO2 Tax Raise Gasoline and Electricity Price

It looks from this article like a $100/ton CO2 tax would raise a gallon of gasoline by $.80 and raise electricity cost by about 36%. Seems to me that this should not be such a big deal and I think at $100/ton it might be enough to remove CO2 from the air.

People would not end up paying that much as electric Companies would produce more not CO2 producing methods and Petroleum prices would be lower than they'd otherwise be and people would tend to buy vehicles that get higher mileage. 

Thursday, October 5, 2023

Better than MMT

My comments on this MMT video.

I'm one of the few Libertarians who think MMT would not be so bad. It would not change much.

MMT does not say deficits do not matter it says that they can cause inflation and that would require cutting spending and/or raising taxes. To understand this it good to think not about money, but about goods and services.

So if you do a Green New Deal and it draws resources away from more productive uses to less productive uses, that is waste, which is why instead of Green New Deal, a CO2 tax and a payout for the removal of CO2 from the air would be better than an MMT funded Green New Deal. 

In fact we already have a mini Green New Deal new in the form of CAFE standards. The paragraph below shows how poorly it works:

"I and other scientists at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology estimate that the new standards will cost the economy on the whole — for the same reduction in gas use — at least six times more than a federal gas tax of roughly 45 cents per dollar of gasoline. That is because a gas tax provides immediate, direct incentives for drivers to reduce gasoline use, while the efficiency standards must squeeze the reduction out of new vehicles only. The new standards also encourage more driving, not less."

So that's a huge waste of the scarcest resource, human effort.

A function of taxes not mentioned in the video, is to let voters know, as much as possible, how much Government functions are costing. They always cost something. You could for that purpose do the opposite of MMT and insist that all government be funded through taxes and let the Federal Reserve provide all the money to the economy even if that requires keeping interest rates at 0% forever and even buying assets in down turns. I think that I would prefer that because the incidence of Government spending falls on the citizens one way or another, all of it, and so the citizens as much as possible the citizens should know the costs.

Friday, September 8, 2023

From ChatGPT Income Quintiles and Church Attendance

This is ChatGPT's answer to: In the USA people from which income quintile are most likely to attend church regularly.


According to the web search results, people from the highest income quintile are most likely to attend church regularly in the USA. The web search results show that:

These results suggest that there is an inequality gap in church attendance based on income levels. However, these results do not necessarily imply a causal relationship between income and church attendance, as there may be other factors involved. For example, some studies have found that social capital, education, and health are also related to church attendance3. Therefore, more research is needed to understand the complex dynamics of income and church attendance in the USA.